CIEL Letter to World Bank President over Tanzania Arrests

 

November 2001

---

Bank Information Center * Both ENDS * Center for International Environmental Law *
The Corner House * Earth Rights International * Environmental Defense *
50 Years Is Enough: U.S. Network for Global Economic Justice * Friends of the Earth US *Friends of the Earth International * Institute for Policy Studies * Mineral Policy Center * Mining Watch * NGO Working Group on the Export Development Corporation * Pacific Environment * Philippine Indigenous Peoples Links *

---

November 28th, 2001

James Wolfensohn, President
The World Bank
1818 H Street, NW
Washington, DC 20433
Fax: 202.522-0355

Dear Mr. Wolfensohn,

Re: Bulyanhulu Gold Mine, Tanzania: Arrest of LEAT lawyer

We, the undersigned organizations, are writing to express grave concern at the arrest on Saturday night of Mr. Rugemeleza Nshala, President of the Lawyers' Environmental Action Team (LEAT) and of Mr. Augustine Mrema, Chairman of the Tanzanian Labor Party. LEAT is a Tanzanian NGO, which has been actively investigating allegations of widespread human rights abuses associated with the Bulyanhulu Gold Mine in Tanzania. Specifically, LEAT has been investigating allegations of killings, illegal evictions and destruction of livelihoods when the site was cleared of artisanal miners in August 1996. As you know, MIGA approved in 2000 a US $172 million MIGA political risk insurance to Barrick Gold Corporation, owner of the mine since 1999 for the mine's development.

We now understand that Mr. Nshala has been released on police bond but is required to report daily to the Dar es Salaam Central Police Station. We also understand that he may be facing charges of sedition. The police also searched the house of Mr. Tundu Lissu, a lawyer with LEAT who has been speaking on this matter internationally, including in Washington with MIGA staff. All indications are that the police would have arrested Mr. Lissu had he been in the country. In the course of these raids, the police reportedly seized evidence given to LEAT by its clients -the families of the small scale miners -- violating lawyer-client privilege and putting these families potentially at risk for police intimidation.

The arrests and raids follow LEAT's recent efforts on the Bulyanhulu case. Two weeks ago, LEAT wrote to the Director of Criminal Investigation, expressing its view that the police did not have the moral authority to re-investigate the killings, given their alleged complicity in the crimes. LEAT also declined to hand over the police videotape of the events that it had obtained, until the police provided the information they claimed disprove the allegations of the killings.

Last Monday (November 19th), LEAT held a press conference in which it reiterated its call for an international commission of inquiry to investigate the alleged killings at Bulyanhulu. LEAT is demanding that any charges against Mr. Nshala, Mr. Lissu, Mr. Mrema and all others arrested in relation to this case be dropped, that the NGO status of LEAT be protected, and that an independent commission of inquiry into the Bulyanhulu allegations be set up immediately. We support these demands.

We believe that the police raid is an attempt to intimidate LEAT and other proponents of the commission of inquiry into silence. In our view, the arrest and raids constitutes a serious violation of the fundamental human right to free speech, a free press, and to unfettered participation in the political process. Given that the arrest and the raids relate directly to LEAT's investigation of a MIGA-backed project, we believe that the World Bank should intervene with the Tanzanian authorities to express its concern and call for a halt to this harassment. We are asking you as President of the World Bank Group and MIGA to use your office to ensure that Mr Nshala's, Mr. Lissu's and the others' human rights are protected and that a thorough, independent and public investigation is carried out.

We thank you in advance for your attention and look forward to your soonest reply,

Sincerely,

Emilie Thenard
Center for International Environmental Law, US

For CIEL and:

Steve Herz
Friends of the Earth US

Shannon Lawrence
Environmental Defense, US

Steve D'Esposito
Mineral Policy Center, US

Joan Kuyek
Mining Watch, Canada

Emilie Revil
NGO Working Group on the Export Development Corporation, Canada

Geoff Nettleton
Philippine Indigenous Peoples Links.

Graham Saul
Bank Information Center

Soren Ambrose
50 Years Is Enough: U.S. Network for Global Economic Justice, US

Gert de Bruijne
Both ENDS, Netherlands

Daphne Wysham
Institute for Policy Studies, US

Doug Norlen
Pacific Environment, US

Rick Herz
Earth Rights International

Johan Frijns
Friends of the Earth International

Sarah Sexton
The Cornerhouse, UK

cc: Meg Taylor, Compliance Advisor Ombudsman
Motomichi Ikawa, Executive Vice President, Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency